But what actually happened is:
- I pressed the hotkey.
- The transmogrify dialog appeared with one item on it.
- I pressed the "a" key.
- The game snuck a NEW DIALOG in as I was pressing "a", and my "a" answered the NEW dialog, which was "choose your reward".
- Pressed "a" again to transmogrify the stupid staff.
- Looked in the "j"ournal to see what I got. +1 Magic. I would not have chosen that.