Just finished the game with, well, the only option currently available. I found it fun, and relatively well-balanced. By the endgame, I was playing almost strictly as a tank, using Chasm and Teluric Fist for extra punchiness against the final bosses, with occasional Detonations, Silicine Slicers, and Catapult for variety. Overall, I think it was about the same difficulty as a general melee character like a berzerker, with extra durability and some nice powers as a trade-off for some of the more specialized weapon skills. I went with Antimagic, even though I don't normally care for it (too much trade-off, imho, losing access to too many items in return for meh powers), because the race seemed tailor-made for Antimagic. I didn't really get much mileage out of it myself, but for players who enjoy Antimagic, it complemented the race/class pretty well.
Some thoughts:
*It seems odd that NPCs can have Jadir/Elemental powers, given that the Jadir powers and Elemental race are inextricable. One wouldn't expect to find a random Rare Forest Troll using Jadir powers. Not sure how easy it would be to code it so nothing except a possible Elemental NPC can get the powers, but it's something to think about.
*There was a nice progression of powers that were strong early but weak later, and vice versa. For instance, Rock Mortar was strong in the early game but mostly useless in late game, which is a good sign of balanced progression.
*Perhaps it could be made clearer from the start that Weapons Mastery/Armor Training don't work quite as well for the class. I'm unclear on the coding, but it seemed that the Jadir powers supplanted rather than augmented parts of the basic Combat Training Tree? If I'm mistaken in my understanding, please correct me, but I didn't see any apparent improvement in some areas when I tested Weapons Mastery, for instance.
*It would have been nice if the description for Earthen Gun had been a tiny bit clearer. It ultimately proved to be an excellent power that I got a lot of mileage out of, but, for instance, it used multiple shots when piercing and I couldn't tell if that was intentional, and I wasn't certain if everything except the actual damage was applied to the shots or if only certain powers/stats were.
*I got a few errors, but most of them seemed unrelated to this add-on (I used a lot of add-ons, as you can see from my character page, because I just didn't bother turning them off, though most of them had no influence on this game except to give me a bit more variety and give enemies more ways to hurt me, heh.) The only exception came when I encased emperor wight in Primordial Stone and the game did that infinite loop of error pop-ups thing that one occasionally sees. I had to abort and reload. The rest actually seemed related to Arcanum class pack, which had little to do with my Antimagic-using self, so I don't know if the problem was with that add-on alone or with the interaction between that one and this one.
*I didn't try the Eyal Resolver Tree, so I can't comment on it. Barehand fighting did seem pretty apt for the class, but thematic considerations wilted under the fact that it seemed overall less effective than using weapons, considering that the strength of a brawler lies heavily in the extra skills the class brings to the table. The choices of handwear didn't seem sufficient to compensate for this difference.
*Despite the fact that shield usage was encouraged by several of the class/race skills, I eschewed them because, even without a shield, my resistances and durability seemed quite sufficient, so the extra damage was preferable for me. The Plate of Genesis was pretty neat and I wore only that once I was able to put points in that skill.
*The toughest part was mid-game or so (but isn't it usually?) and the relative lack of mobility options made things occasionally dicey against tough spellcasters. I often found myself using Primordial Stone more as a pinpoint phase door-type power to close in on/escape an opponent than as a weapon.
*Is there any way to prevent suffocation sand walls for a Jadir? It seems logical that an earth elemental type, more so than any other race, should be able to survive with ease in that situation.
*Any chance of upgrading Temper Weapon to take advantage of the greater variety of weapons offered in Weapons Pack add-on, which is a favorite of mine?
*Small suggestion: allow free targeting of Detonation using keyboard rather than forcing us to go to the mouse if we want to target anything other than an opposing foe. If we use Pinpoint Toss to stick a rock under an enemy, it's fine, but I generally used Chasm, which meant I had to go to the mouse to move the target of Detonation to one of the rocks behind/beside an enemy.
I'm sure I had more thoughts, mostly positive, but they're escaping me right now. Overall, though, I had a lot of fun with this add-on and am looking forward to updates giving us other elementals (water, fire, and air, one assumes.)
http://te4.org/characters/8530/tome/8c4 ... 303883d449
