ToME: the Tales of Maj'Eyal

...who provides

1. Elixir of the Psyche = +5% mental crit chance
2. Elixir of Pnflitration = +5% resistance penetration all
3. Elixir of relief = +5% stun immunity

If you collect all of his goods, you get Gem of Free Will = tier 5 gem that infused to provide 100% blindness and 100% confusion immunity.

...or something along those lines.

Just my two bobs worth!!

I like the general idea, especially the mental crit chance, but +5% stun immunity doesn't seem like much to me, considering you can get +60% with a tier 5 gem. +10% may be better, or maybe something else. Maybe +1 Category point, though that may be too much for an alchemist potion. Maybe a permanent bonus to HP regen?

As for the gem, I'd say confusion, daze, and pinning immunity would fit better with a name like that.

5th alchemist seems like a good idea all right. Although where to put them? And I THINK that adding a fifth alchemist would have the side effect of making it possible to get six alchemist potions.

I'm sure the idea would need refining. It was a conversation starter hopefully.

The main thing I think missing is the mental crit chance potion. I hope DG can work this idea up.

Could keep it at 4 alchemists, and randomise what potions each one is trying to make.

Or replace one of the less useful potions with +mcrit% (the +4 stats or stoneskin ones comes to mind).

I personally feel the +defense one is the most useless. Get rid of that sucker.

And so the same dude dosent have 2 +crit potions, give swap the new + mental crit with the stoneskin.

I think mental crit potion was left out because cunning give mindpower and crit so mental characters already have plenty of crit.