Possession 401: Barehand vs. Many Hands

Anything that has spoilers in it should go in here

Moderator: Moderator

Post Reply

Possession: GWoP Barehand or Marilith/Watcher Swordsmen?

Great Wyrm o' Power
10
56%
Marilith/Watcher
8
44%
 
Total votes: 18

Message
Author
MCKelly
Thalore
Posts: 130
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 7:26 pm
Location: Steel Country

Possession 401: Barehand vs. Many Hands

#1 Post by MCKelly »

Interesting story...my possessor in the Halls of Mandos managed to find an Ent kicking around and followed him around. Sat back and watched him pummel a Marilith, which I then possessed. And I had a Defender and a sentient dagger to try out. Sweet. :D

Here's the kicker, though...also managed to collect several scrolls of Summon Never-Moving Pet, and (after three molds) managed to get a Master Q out of the deal! After pumping 12 quick points into lormastery, I made him my companion, and he summoned a bunch of nasties to take out a bunch of dragons. Sorting through the corpses, I find a GWoP! :shock: Special thanks go out to the RNG for falling asleep and not noticing me.

Here's the dilemma, though: I dunno whether to boost weaponmastery and stick with the Marilith (and potentially Da Watcha in da Wata), or to get Barehand from FF and boost that in my GWoP. Narthanc is not too powerful yet (nor will it be in the future, if RNG wakes up). I know this has been debated several times before in many threads, but I need expert opinions on this situation in particular. I've never seen so much potential with one char before (since many of mine end up in the ground by clvl 20 or so) and I wanna take it slow and plan ahead.

Course, I might also find DarkGod...
"Consummate V's! I SAID CONSUMMATE! Sheesh! You wouldn't know majesty if it came up and bit you in the face!" - SB

LordBucket
Uruivellas
Posts: 929
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2004 2:08 am
Location: Orange County, Ca

#2 Post by LordBucket »

Arguments could be made either way as to whether the Watcher or a Greater Wyrm of Power is the better body in the long run, but i suppose your concern is staying alive in th short run.

Two ways to look at it:

1)Spend those points on weaponmastery right away. More damage now means better chances to live, and right now the marilith with a few weapons and some points in both Combat and Weaponmastery is going to hit a lot more often and do a lot more damage than a GWoP with points in Combat only and no Barehanded. If you want to go barehanded, you'll want to keep those points in reserve until you have the .5 modifer, but it would be sad to die before you ever had the chance.

2) With a Master Quylthulg summoning for you, you don't need to do any damage. You just need to stay alive. Three times as many hit points, and more innate resistances, your odds of not dying are a lot better in the GWoP. You won't be spending those points on barehanded anytime soon, so you can bide your time and wait to decide until you know for sure that you'll get the Watcher's corpse, or .5 barehanded, or both.

Personally, I'd lean towards #2, but my summoners tend to have pets turn on them, so i don't like depending on them. Plus, as Lord Dimwit says, "hit pionts keep you alive." Though, I suppose I would also consider resistance coverage. Even though the GWoP has more naturally, it might be easier to fill the holes with a Marilith. Though...if it came down to something like "1000hp and resist everything," with a marilith or "2000hp and resist everything except nexus" with the GWoP I'd probably still take the Wyrm.

How high were you planning on taking Corpse preservation? Thinking long-term, if you don't actually get the Watcher's body, I'd almost always take the Wyrm over a kraken or a Maralith.

Serin
Sher'Tul
Posts: 1004
Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2004 8:24 pm
Location: LOST

#3 Post by Serin »

as a possessor, go for the hands, if you were a lore-master I would go for the bare-handed GWoP, only because it can get you ancalagon, who is even more powerful! but if you're a possessor, stick with weaponmastery.
Eyes burning, reaction rate diminished, vocabulary deteriorating...you have just been infected with the TOME addiction bug causing you to stay up to the wee hours of the morning playing this great game! :D

MCKelly
Thalore
Posts: 130
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 7:26 pm
Location: Steel Country

#4 Post by MCKelly »

Good point...but how much more powerful is Ancalagon? Is there an HP boost over what the Wyrm gives me? I'm assuming he's got similar powers in the "call for your kids" department...and what about Glaurung? I would imagine that the Father of the Dragons would be infinitely more powerful than anything across the board.

I guess I'm just a little wary of Unique dragons. I possessed Smaug a while back and was disappointed. Not a huge HP bonus, powers paling in comparison to GWoP, etc. Can I expect similar results from the others?
"Consummate V's! I SAID CONSUMMATE! Sheesh! You wouldn't know majesty if it came up and bit you in the face!" - SB

Serin
Sher'Tul
Posts: 1004
Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2004 8:24 pm
Location: LOST

#5 Post by Serin »

well, here is a dump with Ancalagon I don't have one with a GWoP anymore, anyway, he can breathe and summon for massive destruction. Made the game relatively easy really.
Eyes burning, reaction rate diminished, vocabulary deteriorating...you have just been infected with the TOME addiction bug causing you to stay up to the wee hours of the morning playing this great game! :D

Faeryan
Sher'Tul
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2004 5:01 pm
Location: Finland

#6 Post by Faeryan »

Just today I battled all three of those dragons mentioned above. Smaug was child's play, Glaurung was.. like some other wyrm, but Ancalagon.. sheesh! That reptile sure was tough. I'd go with A if I had to pick one of those 3.

Of course everyone remembers their run-ins with those dragons, but I just had to say that cause I had just met 'em.
Stronk is a potent combatant with a terrifying appearance.

LordBucket
Uruivellas
Posts: 929
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2004 2:08 am
Location: Orange County, Ca

#7 Post by LordBucket »

Exact results will vary, but the ratios should be the same.

(Tested with Level 50 Human Posessor with 28 Consitution)

Player body: 688 hp, 0AC, 0 speed

AMHD: 944 hp, 100AC, +10 speed
Smaug: 1045 hp, 150AC, +10 speed
Glaurung: 4265 hp, 125AC, +20 speed
GWoP: 4372 hp, 160AC, +20 speed
Ancalagon: 6278 hp, 170AC, +30 speed

Damage, with 1.0 Combat and 0.0 Barehanded

AMHD
3 attacks / round
damage: 22-157

Smaug
4 attacks / round
damage: 25-243

Glaurung
4 attacks / round
damage: 33-351

GWoP
4 attacks / round
damage: 43-479

Ancalagon
4 attacks / round
damage: 47-527

And here are their racial abliities:

Smaug
a) 1 Breathe Fire
b) 3 Cause Critical Wounds
c) 1 Confusion

Ancient Multi-Hued Dragon
a) 1 Breathe Acid
b) 1 Breathe Lightning
c) 1 Breathe Fire
d) 1 Breathe Cold
e) 1 Breathe Poison
f) 1 Scare
g) 1 Blindnses
h) 1 Confusion

Glaurung, Father of all Dragons
a) 1 Breathe Fire
b) 1 Breathe Poison
c) 3 Breathe Sound
d) 1 Scare
e) 1 Blindness
f) 1 Confusion
g) 9 Summon High Dragon

Ancalagon the Black
a) 1 Breathe Acid
b) 1 Breathe Fire
c) 3 Breathe Time
d) 3 Breathe Force
e) 4 Breathe Disintegration
f) 8 Summon Kin
g) 9 Summon High Dragon

Greater Wyrm of Power
a) 1 Breathe Acid
b) 1 Breathe Lightning
c) 1 Breathe Fire
d) 1 Breathe Cold
e) 1 Breathe Poison
f) 3 Breathe Nether
g) 2 Breathe Light
h) 2 Breathe Dark
i) 1 Breathe Confusion
j) 3 Breathe Sound
k) 3 Breathe Chaos
l) 3 Breathe Disenchantment
m) 3 Breathe Nexus
n) 3 Breathe Time
o) 3 Breathe Inertia
p) 3 Breathe Gravity
q) 3 Breathe Shards
r) 3 Breathe Plamsa
s) 3 Breathe Force
t) 4 Breathe Mana
u) 4 Breathe Nuke
v) 4 Breathe Disintegration
w) 8 Summon Kin
x) 7 Summon Dragon
y) 9 Summon High Dragon

And innate powers/resistances:

Glaurung, Father of all Dragons
Resist: Fire and Poison
Other: Levitation

Smaug, the Golden
Resist: Fire
Other: Reflection, Levitation

Ancalagon the Black
Resist: Base4, Poison and Confusion
Other: Levitation

Ancient Multi-Hued Dragon
Resist: Base4, Poison, Confusion
Other: Free Action, Levitation

Greater Wyrm of Power
Resist: Base4, Poison, Confusion, Nether, Nexus, Disenchantment
Other: Reflection, Free action, Levitate, Aura Fire, Aura Electricity

Summary
So...Smaug is only barely better than an AMHD, and even then, only if you have the right equipment. I can easily see taking an AHMD over Smaug.

Glaurung is much better than either of them, but sorely lacking in resistances.

A GWoP a easily better than any of the previous three, hands down, in every way.

Ancalagon has half again more hit points, and 10 more speed than a GWoP, but is a bit lacking is resistances which you'll need equipment to make up for. I can see choosing a GWoP over Ancalagon because of resistance holes, but the choice might be t ough.

Faeryan
Sher'Tul
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2004 5:01 pm
Location: Finland

#8 Post by Faeryan »

Well that was detailed.. Thanks for the info!
Needs some determination to go and try out all that.
Stronk is a potent combatant with a terrifying appearance.

MCKelly
Thalore
Posts: 130
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 7:26 pm
Location: Steel Country

#9 Post by MCKelly »

Agreed...very detailed, and extremely useful! Thanks much! :D

Is that all done with 50 points in Possession? I understand that Possession skill also affects HP in a body.
"Consummate V's! I SAID CONSUMMATE! Sheesh! You wouldn't know majesty if it came up and bit you in the face!" - SB

Serin
Sher'Tul
Posts: 1004
Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2004 8:24 pm
Location: LOST

#10 Post by Serin »

nice job lord Bucket! taking all that time to find out that info! :D
and yes, mckelly, that should be with a 50 in possession, your hp would be considerably less if you didn't have 50.
Eyes burning, reaction rate diminished, vocabulary deteriorating...you have just been infected with the TOME addiction bug causing you to stay up to the wee hours of the morning playing this great game! :D

LordBucket
Uruivellas
Posts: 929
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2004 2:08 am
Location: Orange County, Ca

#11 Post by LordBucket »

You're welcome, and yes, that was tested with 50 Possession.

Possessors are my favorite class to play. Maybe one day I'll actually make it through Mordor with one. :P

Post Reply